On March 24, 2011 double amputee Oscar Pistorius, the South African athlete running on prosthesis, ran just 0.06 seconds short of the ‘A’ standard needed to qualify for the London Olympics in 2012. Oscar Pistorius, 24 years old, was born with congenital absence of the fibulae in both legs, which were amputated just below the knees when he was 11 months old. His case spurred debate four years ago, when he was banned from running with able-bodied athletes on grounds that his prosthesis gave him an “unfair” competitive edge over able-bodied athletes. Oscar appealed to the supreme Court of Arbitration for Sport (Lausanne), which in May 2008 reversed the sentence, and judged that Oscar does not have an unfair advantage over the other “able bodied” athletes and ruled he could run in the Olympics, provided he met the A qualifying entry time, a goal that seems to be getting closer and closer for the South-African runner. Pistorius’ case sparked debate on the construction of categories in sports: to what extent are they based on categories existing in nature, and to what are they instead a social construction? Also, to what extent is the construction of these categories informed by science and medicine and to what by ethics, philosophy and eventually law? What does it mean to be able, or disabled, in sports? Is it legitimate to talk about super-ability, enhancement and post-humans for the case of Oscar Pistorius? When can enhancement be considered doping? These are only some of the questions that arise when considering the effect of mechanical prostheses on the athletes, and when reflecting on how our concept of an Olympic athlete is going to be shaped by different kinds of enhancements and to change over the next twenty years. But they are by no means the only pressing questions concerning the construction of categories in the Olympics. Rules concerning gender verification tests, and policy regulating gene gene doping are just two more examples that will be at the forefront at the London Olympics in one year. Stay tuned on this blog for more posts on ethics and sports. Meanwhile, take note that Oscar Pistorius is going to run at the Paralympic World Cup in Manchester, on May 27th. I will be there to report!
- Read @NeilVickers2’s review of Jonathan Sklar’s ”Balint Matters" for @MedHums_BMJ here: go.shr.lc/2tMaHcR 5 days ago
- Read @NeilVickers2 “Confessions of a medical humanist” on the King’s English website: blogs.kcl.ac.uk/english/2017/0… 1 month ago
- Read Neil Vickers’ “Confessions of a medical Humanist” on the Kings’ English blog: blogs.kcl.ac.uk/english/2017/0… 1 month ago